Having achieved its aim to deregulate plants made using new GM techniques (NGTs), the European Commission is now trying the same thing with GM microorganisms (GMMs) – including viruses and bacteria – an area where the risks are even greater. Many scientists are warning against the possible consequences of the plan. We still have a choice – you can sign a petition to call on politicians to make rational decisions on this crucial topic (GM MICROORGANISMS).
Meanwhile Mexico has approved the world’s first gene silencing RNAi biofungicide (GM PESTICIDES OR “BIOCONTROLS”) – again, to widespread condemnation from scientists. RNAi pesticides are designed to silence the genes of the offending pest – be it an insect or a fungus. The problem is that there’s a real possibility that they could silence the genes of beneficial insects and animals in general, with potentially lethal effects.
GM MICROORGANISMS
No time for scrutiny: How the Commission is ramming through GMMs deregulation
Under the guise of a supposedly urgent need for action to deregulate GMMs, the European Commission has cut corners by failing to consult the public on this issue and by withholding certain documents, including a key “impact assessment”.
EU Commission’s plan to fast-track releases of GMMs threatens human health and microbiome

The European Commission has proposed the deregulation of open releases of GMMs into the environment, including a ‘fast track’ procedure to approve releases of some GMMs. GeneWatch UK’s report “GM microbes and the microbiome” discusses the implications:
• The human microbiome is a complex system in which many species of bacteria and other microorganisms interact with each other, their environment, and their human host. It plays an important role in human health which is not fully understood.
• GMMs pose risks because they are living organisms, which evolve rapidly and interact with other organisms and the wider environment once they are released, including with the human microbiome.
• The EU’s proposed new “expedited” (fast-track) procedure is completely inadequate to protect human health and the microbiome.
See Save Our Seeds’ article on the plan and Inf’OGM’s article from last year, “The majority of microorganisms modified by NGTs [new genomic techniques] are detectable”.
Some improvements won, but a long way to go
On 10 November the European Parliament’s Environment, Climate and Food Safety Committee (ENVI) and Public Health Committee (SANT) voted on the deregulation of GMMs in a joint session. Amendments led to some improvements in the Commission’s proposal:
• All GMM authorisations will be reviewed after 10 years, based on a new risk assessment and monitoring results.
• All GMMs must be detectable. Applicants must always submit a “method capable of detection” (but not identification and quantification) even when EU detection requirements are “adapted”. They must also “deposit the DNA sequence of the GMM and of its parental organism, together with reference material” for national enforcement authorities.
• Post-market monitoring remains mandatory for all GMMs through the first 10 years of EU authorisation.
However, more changes are needed, including the possibility of Member State opt-outs and registers of release sites. Let’s hope Members of the European Parliament can introduce these further amendments when the European Parliament holds its plenary vote on 25 November.
TAKE ACTION: Sign the petition against uncontrolled release of GM microorganisms
No loopholes. No shortcuts. Nature is not a laboratory. You can sign regardless of which country you are in.
MORE EU AND US CALLS FOR CAUTION

In an op-ed for Le Monde, a group of over 60 scientists are calling on the European Commission to suspend the draft directive on the placing on the market of GMMs. They warn that relaxing the regulations could have serious consequences and urge a “more measured” reflection on these issues. The scientists comment on the speed with which the Commission is moving with its proposal: “The Commission itself acknowledges that the political urgency cited prevented the completion of an impact assessment within the required timeframe. Member states are therefore being asked to endorse a framework that could have long-lasting effects on human health, the environment, and society – all without a rigorous, critical assessment of the risks involved, which concern complex, historically evolved, non-linear, and deeply interconnected living systems.” See also this webinar by concerned scientists: Genetically Engineered Microorganisms – Opportunities and Risks.
Ecologists denounce EU Commission plan to deregulate GM microorganisms
A group of ecologists has written a report explaining why the European Commission’s plan to weaken the regulations around GMMs is a terrible idea. They write: “Microbes are fundamentally different from plants and animals in ways that make current or loosened regulatory approaches inappropriate and potentially dangerous. We also lack sufficient scientific knowledge about identity and ecology of microbes.” They warn about “the impossibility of removing GMMs once they are applied”. The ecologists want certain assumptions to be removed from the Commission’s proposal – namely that there is a “low-risk” category of microbes and that a “Qualified Presumption of Safety” (QPS) can be made for these organisms. Under the proposal, these assumptions would be used to justify weakening or abolishing the risk assessment for a GMM.
GMO microbes pose simultaneous risks for humans, bees and plants
Testbiotech is warning against the EU Commission's proposal to enable fast-track releases of GM microbes that could result in negative effects on natural microbial communities necessary to maintain the health of plants, animals and humans. Testbiotech research shows that around 40 species of microbes being considered for fast-track releases when genetically engineered, are found in honeybees and bee products. Many of them are also part of the microbiomes of soil, plants, animals and humans. So care is needed.
US scientists warn of inadequate regulation of GMMs
In a recent publication, scientists warn of the inadequate regulation of GMMs in the US, as Testbiotech reports. Using three case studies, they highlight significant gaps in risk assessment before market approval. According to their findings, a fragmented approval system with unclear responsibilities and insufficient approval standards causes risks for health and the environment not being adequately assessed. The three examples involve genetically engineered bacteria that have already been approved in the US. They are intended to capture nitrogen in the soil, aid in tooth brushing, or mitigate the effects of alcohol consumption. Although the companies submitted some dossiers, the authorities did not conduct a sufficient review. According to the publication, risks such as unintended changes to the microbiome, spread into the environment, and human-to-human transmission were omitted. The scientists make recommendations regarding what a minimum standard for risk assessment and regulation should entail.
GM PESTICIDES OR “BIOCONTROLS”
Scientists warn of dangers as Mexico approves world’s first gene silencing RNAi biofungicide

Mexico has approved the world’s first RNAi (RNA interference – a GM gene silencing technology) biofungicide – and scientists are warning about the risks. The technology “is not an innovation compatible with human rights standards”, biologist Erica Hagman Aguilar warns. This is because it fails to comply with the constitutional mandate of the precautionary principle regarding risks to public health and the environment. The biofungicide, marketed as Oifirax, is specifically approved to combat grape powdery mildew, a fungal disease caused by the pathogen Erysiphe necator. The product uses targeted double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) via spray-induced gene silencing to deactivate genes in fungi that cause diseases in plants. However, scientists warn that these molecules could silence or otherwise disrupt the genes of beneficial and non-target insects, as well as humans and other animals, with unknown but potentially fatal consequences. In an in-depth article on the approval, Claire Robinson explores the background issues and – with the help of Erica Hagman Aguilar, who was previously responsible for public policies and regulations at Mexico’s biosafety agency – how this development relates to Mexican President Claudia Sheinbaum’s constitutional ban on the planting of GM corn in Mexico.
Organisations in Oaxaca warn of ecological disaster due to the RNA biofungicide the Mexican govt is promoting
Representatives of organisations within the ‘State Alliance for the Defence of Oaxaca’s Native Maize’ warned of an ecological disaster due to the RNA biofungicide the Mexican government – including the federal government’s Secretary of Economy, Marcelo Ebrard Casaubón – is promoting (see above). The groups say the use of different forms of genetic engineering of crops, insects and other organisms represents new environmental dangers, as well as biosafety and health risks, to Mexico’s communities and peoples. The organisations pointed out that if it is a fungicide, it is not ‘bio’: “The name says it all: it threatens the life of fungi, and fungi are the driving force behind soil health and agroecology. The bio-fungicide he [Casaubón] is now promoting could cause a disaster for the micro-biodiversity of Mexico’s smallholder soils.” The organisations added that these new technologies are in the hands of the same companies that control agrochemicals and GM crops, such as Bayer-Monsanto, Corteva, and Syngenta.
Genetically engineered pesticides: Safety unknown but in question
Sarah Zanon Agapito-Tenfen is Science Director of the Rio Institute in Paris and a Project Development Specialist with the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO). She was part of a recent international task force of about 20 scientists that reviewed more than 40 years’ worth of studies on genetically engineered pesticides, including RNAi (gene silencing) products. Speaking at a webinar organised by the African Centre for Biodiversity (ACB), she said that out of 700 research papers the task force examined, just 23 looked into the GE pesticides’ effects beyond their target species – and half of these lacked controls to make them valid studies. Of the dozen studies the task force deemed sound – all looking at the impacts of RNAi sprays – 11 detected effects on non-target organisms. Agapito-Tenfen said this means there is still a lot of missing information about how RNAi pesticides might affect, for instance, fungi that help plant roots absorb water and nutrients from the soil, or pollinators like bees. “This is not a large literature with gaps. This is a very small literature. Whole parts of the picture are missing,” Agapito-Tenfen said.







