NOTE: If you live in India, please ask the Chief Minister in your State to oppose the BRAI bill – it threatens our food safety
http://www.greenpeace.in/take-action/save-your-food/write-to-your-CM.php?tyf=tw
–-
–-
India's New GM Crops Bill is a Gross Example of Corruption
Natasha Malpani
http://www.policymic.com/articles/2548/india-s-new-gm-crops-bill-is-a-gross-example-of-corruption
India's agricultural future looks bleak as the Biotechnology Regulatory Authority of India (BRAI) Bill 2011 is scheduled to pass in the current session of Indian parliament. This highly controversial bill calls for the formation of a new regulatory body that is the ultimate authority on the introduction of Genetically Modified (GM) crops in India.
This body makes a mockery of both consumer protection as well as farmer rights, as it stipulates that the body will be made up of five members based within the Department of Biotechnology (DBT), the very body that funds GM crop research in the country. To add to the irony, the DBT is also the main agency for channeling funds from foreign governments to GM crop development projects.
In 2010, mass protests across the country stalled the introduction of GM Brinjal (aubergine). The Environment Minister was compelled to take public opinion into account and a moratorium on GM foods crops was installed. In a blatantly undemocratic move, failing to take into account public protests, this bill now allows biotechnology companies to bulldoze the Environment Ministry as well as state governments. This single-window clearance body unconstitutionally denies state government’s authority over agriculture and health issues as the bill explicitly states that the final decision related to GM crops will be taken by the Union government. This is convenient, as several states’ Chief Ministers have already expressed severe doubts over the contents of the bill.
Their worries are not baseless. The bill makes provision for open-air field trials of GM crops that have previously been banned, and allows non-accredited labs to conduct bio-safety assessment tests. Even more worryingly however, it overrides the RTI (Right to Information Act 2005) that was formulated to allow transparency of governance in the first place, and prevents consumers from accessing information about the safety of these new crops.
The repercussions of introducing BT Cotton in India are still reverberating on a national level; there are hundreds of controversial reports linking the crop to farmer debt and suicides, and accusing the Ministry of conducting illegal field trials and tampering with reports. Moreover, Monsanto, the manufacturer of GM cotton seeds in India itself has admitted that BT Cotton has failed in India. The productivity of cotton has fallen while pesticide expenditure has gone up. A Greenpeace report notes that in the year 2009-10, farmers cultivating cotton through organic practices earned 200% more net income than farmers who grew GM cotton.
And yet, India’s Agriculture Minister has stated that the Ministry is "very supportive of GM crop research" and that the government is the process of designing a large number of transgenic crops.
Not a little suspiciously, the BRAI Bill is being pushed by Vilasrao Deshmukh the Science & Technology (S&T) Minister and Sharad Pawar, the Agriculture Minister who has previously staunchly supported Prithviraj Chavan, the last Union Science Minister who also strongly advocated the BT Brinjal bill. It’s not hard to see a pattern here.
This is a blatant case of officials siding with private companies over farmers and completely disregarding public opinion and safety. Ministers within the Parliament itself have said the Bill is both "anti-farmer" and "anti-people," even as hundreds of farmers and environmentalists protest outside Parliament.
While BT Cotton is currently the only GM crop grown in India on a large-scale, there are 56 GM crops under trial. The new BRAI body will be more of a promoter of these crops than a regulator. We cannot risk another GM crop disaster in a country where over 50% of the population relies on agriculture. India is often touted as the world’s largest democracy. If this is true in practice, the BRAI Bill should be scrapped immediately.
- Main Menu
- Home
- News
- Articles
- Videos
- Index of speakers
- Glyphosate Videos
- Gene Editing videos
- Must see videos
- Health Effects
- Agriculture videos
- Labeling videos
- Animals videos
- Corporations videos
- Corporate takeover videos
- Contamination videos
- Latin America videos
- India videos
- Asia videos
- Songs videos
- Protests videos
- Biofuel myths videos
- Index of GM crops and foods
- Contact
- About
- Donations
- News
- Articles
- Donations
-
Videos
- Index of speakers
- Glyphosate videos
- Gene Editing
- Must See videos
- Health Effects
- Agriculture videos
- Labeling videos
- Animals videos
- Corporations videos
- Corporate takeover videos
- Contamination videos
- Latin America videos
- India videos
- Asia videos
- Songs videos
- Protests videos
- Biofuel myths videos
- Index of GM crops and foods
- Contact
- About
News Menu
News Archive
- 2023 articles
- 2022 articles
- 2021 articles
- 2020 articles
- 2019 articles
- 2018 articles
- 2017 articles
- 2016 articles
- 2015 articles
- 2014 articles
- 2013 articles
- 2012 articles
- 2011 articles
- 2010 articles
- 2009 articles
- 2008 articles
- 2007 articles
- 2006 articles
- 2005 articles
- 2004 articles
- 2003 articles
- 2002 articles
- 2001 articles
- 2000 articles
PLEASE SUPPORT GMWATCH
If you like what we do, please help us do more. You can donate via Paypal or credit/debit card. Some of you have opted to give a regular donation. We greatly appreciate that as it helps place us on a more stable financial basis. Thank you for your support!
Web Development By SCS Web Design